Retention Isn’t the Same as Engagement — Leaders Are Rethinking What “Healthy” Actually Looks Like

At first glance, workforce stability looks strong due to the steadiness of retention. Beneath the surface, a different picture is emerging: 73% of members report mixed engagement.This is creating a growing risk for leadership: Are traditional metrics capturing the full picture of workforce health?

Culture & Experience Board poll: How would you describe employee engagement in your organization right now? Top answer: Mixed—some teams engaged, others not, 73%. N=11. Source: Culture & Experience Board Community Call, March 18, 2026.

The Story in Brief

“What’s becoming clear is that retention is no longer a reliable signal of engagement. Many organizations are seeing strong intent to stay alongside declining energy, lower advancement interest, and uneven engagement across teams. The ‘Great Stay’ may reflect caution more than commitment, which makes it critical for leaders to look beyond retention when assessing workforce health.”
Jordona Smith Executive Director, HR Practice Area, Culture & Experience Board

Picking Up the Story

Stability is Masking Low Engagement

At first glance, workforce stability looks strong due to the steadiness of retention. Beneath the surface, a different picture is emerging: 73% of members report mixed engagement.

This is creating a growing risk for leadership: Are traditional metrics capturing the full picture of workforce health?

“We just had a record year, but I saw a lot of griping and discontentment on Glassdoor.”

Poll results

Bar chart. How would you describe employee engagement in your organization right now? (select one) Mixed—some teams engaged, others not 73%; Mostly strong and stable 27%; Declining—seeing signs of disengagement 0%; Hard to tell—signals are inconsistent 0%. N=11. Source: Culture & Experience Board Community Call, March 18, 2026.
Employee Engagement Levels
Bar chart. If you’re observing disengagement, what do you think is the cause? (select all that apply) Workload and burnout 70%; Limited mobility or career stagnation 50%; Change fatigue—just too much, too fast 40%; Manager effectiveness 30%; Trust in leadership or direction of the company 20%. N=10. Source: Culture & Experience Board Community Call, March 18, 2026.
Causes of Employee Disengagement

Focus of the Discussion

Teams Are Facing a New Signal Problem

Employees are staying, but that isn’t the lone factor in engagement.

Organizations reported strong intent to stay metrics, yet lower engagement scores and visible signs of disengagement. As one participant put it, “Intent to stay response was strong… everything else was lower than the benchmark.” Feelings of burnout remain high.

This gap is showing up in behavior. Employees report confidence in their career opportunities, but declining advancement. Managers are a critical pressure point in this system. Employees rely on leaders to interpret and communicate change, but middle managers are often misaligned or uncertain.

Key Takeaways

  1. Productivity metrics remain strong, while other signals, like lower survey benchmarks, declining interest in career advancement, and negative feedback in listening channels, point to a different experience. Several members noted that engagement varies significantly across populations, with leadership teams often described as engaged and supported, while frontline or broader employee groups are less engaged. Others highlighted differences across segments; for example, one member noted higher engagement paired with higher turnover in hourly populations.

  2. For some members, retention no longer appears to be a reliable proxy for engagement. In some cases, employees expressed confidence in their career paths but still declined new opportunities, while others maintained productivity alongside visible dissatisfaction. Members also described inconsistencies across populations, reinforcing that engagement and turnover do not always move together.

  3. Leaders consistently pointed to workload and burnout, limited mobility, and change fatigue as the primary drivers of disengagement. These showed up in examples like concerns about the pace of change, and employees feeling overextended. In a few cases, members described leaders themselves struggling to interpret shifts, which then affects how effectively they support their teams.

  4. Many teams are relying on targeted, practical actions to address disengagement, while acknowledging limits to what they can change. Leaders shared approaches like stay interviews, more intentional 1:1s, recognition efforts, and increased communication, often focused on specific populations like high-potential employees. At the same time, several noted that larger issues, such as workload, pay, or policy constraints, are difficult to influence directly. Some members explicitly described these as “boulders” they cannot move, shaping where they choose to focus their efforts.

About the Culture & Experience Board and Assemble

The Culture & Experience Board is an Assemble community that helps senior culture, workforce experience, and organizational change leaders at the world's largest organizations make better, faster decisions through trusted peer insights.

We selectively share highlights from confidential member conversations to help leaders understand how peers are navigating complex workforce challenges and emerging opportunities.

If you'd like to learn more about the conversations happening inside our peer network, or how members connect with trusted peers to solve critical challenges, please contact us.

Jay Avery hedcut
About the author

Jay Avery

Contributing Editor Jay Avery is a freelance journalist and writer whose work has appeared in The New York Times, Vanity Fair, and Architectural Digest. She began her career in marketing and content roles at Uber during its early startup years and later at RideAustin, bringing a strong foundation in both storytelling and strategic communications. Jay holds a law degree from the University of North Carolina and is based in Raleigh, North Carolina.