The Story in Brief
“The legal headline for the Supreme Court decision on IEEPA tariffs may be settled, but the operational reality is still messy. Companies are spending a huge amount of time tracking tariffs, compliance rules, and now refund mechanics, and there’s no sign that the complexity is going away anytime soon.”
Picking Up the Story
Uncertainty Remains, Despite the Long-Awaited Ruling
For companies that paid tariffs under IEEPA, the Supreme Court ruling raised an immediate operational question: how to get their money back.
Supply chain leaders are left with questions about the government’s current posture, potential refund mechanisms, and the legal strategies their companies may need to consider.
“Even though they’ve been ruled illegal, the money doesn’t automatically get refunded.”
Focus of the Discussion
Examining the Choices Importers Now Face
Welcome to the aftermath of the Supreme Court decision that invalidated tariffs imposed under IEEPA.
While the ruling clarified the legal status of those tariffs, it left companies with an unresolved financial question. Will they receive refunds for duties already paid? As our guest expert Michael Roll of Roll & Harris LLP explained, “The Supreme Court’s not involved in the refund process. All they did was say these tariffs are illegal.” Recovering the funds will likely depend on administrative or legal processes that have not yet been clearly defined.
This lack of clarity has left companies uncertain about their next steps. Importers must now decide whether to wait for the government to issue guidance, or proactively pursue claims. Also, not all importers are currently configured to receive electronic refunds, which may create additional hurdles.
Key Takeaways
The Supreme Court may have settled the legal question on IEEPA tariffs, but the refund fight is just beginning. Michael Roll, Partner at Roll & Harris LLP, said the Supreme Court’s ruling that the IEEPA tariffs were illegal did not answer the question most importers now care about: how refunds will actually happen. This means the operational mess has been pushed down to the lower courts and Customs.
A favorable refund path may be emerging, but companies should not assume the process is settled. As of March 9, 2026, approximately 2,400 cases have been filed. Michael walked through the recent Atmus Filtration, Inc. v. United States case, where Judge Eaton has pushed the government to begin refunding unliquidated and certain not-finally-liquidated entries. The government has argued that the scale is enormous, pointing to tens of millions of entries, hundreds of thousands of importers, and only a small portion of importers are currently set up to receive electronic refunds. Michael’s view was clear: Things may sound like they are moving in the right direction, but appeals, delays, and procedural fights are still very much on the table.
Liquidation status and ACE readiness could determine how easily companies recover refunds. The clearest path to refunds appears to be for unliquidated entries and possibly those liquidated within the past 90 days, since Customs may still have authority to correct them. Older liquidated entries are less certain, and may require a company to have already filed suit or to pursue another legal path. Michael advised companies to ensure their ACE accounts are fully set up, including banking details for electronic refunds.
Even if a broad administrative refund mechanism is eventually created, companies may still want to take action. Michael’s recommendation was to preserve rights where possible until there is final clarity. He acknowledged that the wait-and-see approach may look more reasonable than it did earlier, but there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The right strategy ultimately depends on each company’s exposure, timing, and appetite for risk.
Section 122 is the next important battleground. New lawsuits challenging the Section 122 tariffs are already underway. Michael’s view: These cases may be more difficult than the IEEPA challenge because the legal authority under Section 122 expressly allows tariffs for a limited period, if there is a balance-of-payments crisis. The issue may come down less to statutory interpretation and more to whether courts are willing to second guess the administration’s rationale about what constitutes a crisis (which courts have historically been reluctant to do).
About the Supply Chain Board and Assemble
The Supply Chain Board is an Assemble community that helps senior supply chain leaders at the world's largest companies make better, faster decisions through trusted peer insights.
We selectively share highlights from confidential member conversations to help leaders understand how peers are navigating complex challenges and fast-moving, high-stakes moments.
If you'd like to learn more about the conversations happening inside our peer network, or how members connect with trusted peers to solve critical challenges, please contact us.